Skip directly to content

Glee

Watching Glee: Choke

on Wed, 2012-05-02 12:16

Sigh.

Glee.

Look.

Dot Marie Jones turned in an absolutely beautiful performance as Beiste deals with her abusive husband. I even like the fact there wasn't some easy solution to what is a very difficult and dangerous situation that - despite numerous country songs to the contrary - doesn't lend itself to simple feel-good answers delivered in rhyme.

But it doesn't change the fact that we haven't seen either Beiste or Cooter in months. Months!

How? Am I supposed to invest in characters that vanish like that? Is there a dartboard in the writers' room and they just give it a toss to see who gets to be on the show this week?

I'm not going to get so melodramatic as to claim that Glee is like an abusive relationship. Where it lures me in with promises to reform and then shatters my hopes and dreams in a violent burst of sequins. (I have some sense of the absurd.)

But I'm obviously not getting what I want out of this show.

I want a dense, multi-layered, tightly woven, serialized story that effortlessly mixes humor and drama while building slowly to a perfectly timed end of the season pay-off.

Glee wants to throw things at the screen and see what sticks.

Hell. I can get that from Ringer.

While we do all share an appreciation for the shiny, I'm going to need a little more than Chris Colfer dancing manically on top of a piano in a pair of gold pants as Whoopi Goldberg glowers on from beneath her turban.

I think... I think we're coming to a good stopping point.

The end of the season makes three years and that's long enough. The first group of characters will have graduated, so it's a clean break - despite what I could criticize as unwise attempts to keep them around - no. Not my problem.

Someone else can watch season four. Lots of someones if the ratings are any indication.

I'll just sit here. Alone. In the dark. Thinking to myself that the turtleneck really should have been a warning sign that Cooter was up to no good.

On My Way

Glee Episode Review

In which Rachel and Finn do not go to the chapel and they do not get married. Regionals is almost an after-thought in this dramatic event-filled episode of Glee.

Watching: Glee

on Wed, 2012-02-08 20:28

Spanish Teacher

Do they even have tenure positions at the high school level? I suppose I always assumed that was a university thing.

Yeah. Cuz that's what's important here.

What's important here is that Ricky Martin has really nice arms and in all the attention being paid to his teeth and hips no one pointed out what really nice arms he has. So it falls to me: Ricky Martin has really nice arms.

I liked this episode because Martin brought a lot of fun to it. Kind of like Gwyneth Paltrow's first couple of guest turns. They both just looked like they were enjoying themselves and I responded to that by enjoying their performances.

The actual song selection was a bit of a mixed bag, but I loved the Gloria Estefan / Enrique Eglasias numbers that Mercedes and Sam were singing. And La Isla Bonita was a hit.

Will's Matador Elvis was wrong in all the right ways. I mean it is wrong in "OMG He is not really wearing that?" kind of way. And I love that Santana's arguments were so very good and knocked the well-meaning not-thought-out wind right out Will. (I like it when he's not the source of all wisdom; he's more human.)

Santana's right. Teaching is the thing Will does so that he can do glee club, but that doesn't mean he should neglect his responsibilities. And in that sense, "A Little Less Conversation" was exactly right. It was a glee club performance - which is what Will is good at.

Finally, I am eternally grateful to Coach Bieste for introducing the term "jiggles and bits" into my vocabulary.

Watching: Glee

on Wed, 2012-02-01 12:54

Michael

Manages to convince me that Rachel really did feel desperate enough to accept Finn's proposal. Not that I agree it's remotely a good idea, but Lea Michele sells Rachel's pain. Sells her fear and jealously at seeing first Quinn and then Kurt beaming that smile that says "I know where I'm going."

Sebastian makes for one slimy little bad guy. Even worse than Jesse. I suppose they needed one to vary the drive to Regionals. He's such a cartoon of a character, but kind of fun. We'll take "kind of fun."

I do like that they gave Quinn a happy ending. Or at least the possibility of it; there's still half a season left. Not only do I still like the character, it's just such a relief that the show doesn't feel the need to make everyone miserable. Which is why I'm also rooting for Sam and Mercedes. Or rather, I'm rooting for Mercedes and Sam to be happy and if that's with each other then that's nice.  

There were a lot of nice moments in this episode. Kurt's dad. Cello guys. Artie getting to dance and Mike Chang getting to sing.

But I'm just the tiniest bit disconnected from the overall narrative drive of it. Unlike the first season which had me on the edge of my seat wondering what would happen next, this season is just kind of there and that's okay. Or not. You know. In a Jack Handy kind of way.

Yeah.

Season one was Spike walking through town going, "Well, this is just... neat!" Season three is "And that's... okay."

Watching: Glee

on Wed, 2012-01-18 15:04

Yes/No

Just about everything in this episode would have worked better if the series didn't have the habit of dropping storylines for months on end.

It was a sweet story for Will and Emma. They drag out everything they can do make us think that Emma might say 'no' and I wasn't sure because she could have always pulled out the "What you said to convince yourself convinced me and now you're sure and I'm not" routine. But then every one of his students might have drowned themselves and that would have been messy so I'm glad she accepted the proposal.

Finn and Rachel. Finn's issues have always had to do with his leadership and his drive to prove himself. I have to admit that when Finn announced that he was joining the army, all I could think was that I'd only support that move if he and Rachel got to sing "Do It for Your Country" from Grease 2.

As it was, the moment with Finn's mother was really powerful. That totally rocked the poor boy. I don't think that the answer is to get married straight out of high school, but I can see where Finn thinks he's coming from.

Of course, Rachel isn't likely to say 'yes'. At least, I hope she doesn't say yes. I can't imagine her thinking she can get married and have her Broadway dreams. She's smarter than that, right? But maybe she's feeling low after missing out on the college she wanted. But to buy into that I  have to believe that Rachel didn't have a backup college.

It's a common - yet very annoying - TV story angle to only let characters apply to one college because then you can have such drama when they get rejected. Gossip Girl pulled out the same thing with Blair Waldorf. Like there aren't two hundred schools in New York. Or Rachel and Kurt couldn't pick one school as freshmen and then transfer somewhere else a year later. Or just hit the audition circuit like everyone else on the planet.

In this case, it's necessary to explain why Rachel and Kurt don't go to New York like they've been talking about for years because they have to still be in Ohio next year. So that one school doesn't get back to them and their dreams are crushed and the actors stay on contract. I kind of wish they'd just graduate and then move on to the next generation.

I know everyone's got their favorites (I'm going to be bummed if Blaine ever leaves) but clinging to the stars beyond the natural end of their characters' story isn't a solution. They just wind up over-staying their welcome and making everyone thoroughly sick and tired of seeing their too old for high school faces hanging around. And they already have a problem with cast bloat on this series. Let people go and refocus on the more neglected characters coming up behind them.

But that's a big picture thing. I did like this episode for what it was. I liked Will and Emma. I liked the song choices. Becky insulted Puck's hair and Sue was relatively restrained yet still mocked Artie's driving gloves. It's the little things that make me happy.

And there's this: "I bet you had to overcome a lot with those crooked nipples."

Which will never not be funny.

Watching: Glee

on Wed, 2012-01-11 15:04

The Sue Sylvester Shuffle

Glee replayed their post-Superbowl episode last night. And now that I'm looking at that title, is it really all that appropriate? I suppose she did "shuffle" the regional competition for the cheerleader around, thus prompting the main plot point of the football players having to perform the half-time show.

Anyways.

I want to hone in on a couple of points that this episode really brings up. The first has to do with what I've thought of as McKinley High's "under-developed ecosystem." TV in general tends to narrow its focus (extras cost money, after all) so we rarely venture beyond the football team vs glee club rivalry displayed here. I think that's a huge missed opportunity for Glee.

For example, we see the football team get slushied by the hockey team during their little victory walk. The "Mullet Heads" have been seen before, but their appearance raises the issue for me: where are all the other clubs at McKinley?

Why was the glee club should have been in competition with all the theater folks for West Side Story. But what about that wrestling team that Lauren Zizes is supposedly on? The A/V club? The chess club? Can you imagine how much more effective it would have been for Karofsky to get slushied by a member of the chess club? If that had happened, I might have had a tiniest bit of sympathy for the guy instead of wondering why he folded so easily. (Survey says? Script-dictated meltdown. But of course.)

It also would have come at the bullying angle from a far more complicated and subtle direction. I assume that Karofsky has been bullying more students than just the glee club. Though he might have singled Kurt out specifically for a variety of reasons, there's no evidence that he's actually nice to - well - anyone.

So having the other clubs take their opportunity to have a little back would have been a demonstration of how that kind of behavior spreads and creates these cycles of nastiness. A cycle of slushy violence, if you will.

It also would have given Glee the opportunity to pull out some of that ironic editing and dramatic smash cuts that they like so much some times then completely forget about at others. Which is the second point that came up: the uneven tone of the show.

In one corner, Sue is off setting her cheerleaders on fire and shooting Brittany out of a cannon. Obviously high satire of her drive to win.

And in the other corner, we have a painfully earnest demonstration of how teachers believing that students can change their behavior and bring them together and are you zoning out yet because I am. It's written, acted, directed and edited completely as if we are to invest in Karofsky's emotional conflict and care whether he becomes a good person or not. I complained in the full episode review of "The Sue Sylvester Shuffle" that Karofsky has committed the cardinal sin of being dull, but I think what's really going on is that it seems like his story is the one story that I'm supposed to take seriously but I can't really trust that in the middle of all the crazy.

This is why Sue's character has become so odd-man-out. Because she really is just off on her own doing her own ridiculous thing while the rest of the show is Real Drama. The contrast between Absurd Sue and everyone else winds up pulling everything down. I can't get past Sue as a charicature  because hello human cannonball, but at the same time, I can't really commit to Karofsky because I never know when I'm suddenly going to be pulled over into...

Well. Into the "Sylvester Shuffle."

I Am Unicorn

Glee Episode Review

In which there is a unicorn metaphor. There should always be a unicorn metaphor. Glee gets back on track with some solid character work, including the return of Shelby and little Beth.

Watching: Glee

on Wed, 2011-09-28 13:29

I Am Unicorn

Is no one but the glee club trying out for the musical? I know "the arts" are unpopular, but where are all the drama geeks? Again, we are back to a lack of high school eco-system kind of being a missed opportunity.

That said, I did like this episode. It had more of a coherant throughline to the characters and story. Looks like they will be using the school musical as the event of the half-season which will be way more interesting than yet another run at Sectionals. This show needs a structure and a goal to shape the stories.

I have all sorts of things to say about how deep and meaningful Kurt is, but I'll wait until the longer review. But I will say that Darren Criss OMGNAILEDIT on "Something's Coming." Love.

The Purple Piano Project

Glee Episode Review

In which there are pianos. And they are purple. We're all very excited that Glee is back for its third season, but the premiere episode doesn't exactly achive that thing called "focus."

Season Three

Another season of Glee! While not quite as stoked as I was last year, I'm still interested in seeing what happens.

Pages